Carrot website alternative

The Carrot website alternative you own outright

Carrot rents you a site for $99 to $119 a month, on themes other investors use too. I build a custom we-buy-houses website you own for a one-time price, and move your pages so your Google rankings carry across.

Sohrab Khan, real estate web designerSohrab KhanReal estate web designer. I design your homepage first, free.

Cost over 3 years

Carrot$4,284

Billed monthly: $119 a month, Individual plan, one website

Your own website$1,560–$1,860

$1,200–$1,500 once, plus hosting (about $10 a month)

You keep about $2,400–$2,700 over 3 years, and the site pays for itself within about 14 months.

Price
$1,200–$1,500one time, no monthly fee to me
3-year saving
~$1,700–$2,700against Carrot’s Individual plan
Your rankings
Every URL keptor 301-redirected to the right page
Ownership
100% yourscode, design, content and leads

An honest look

Carrot isn’t bad. It’s rented.

Plenty of investors start on Carrot, and for good reasons. Here’s what it does well, and why so many move off it once the business grows.

What Carrot does well

  • Live in a day: pick a theme, add your logo and you have a site.
  • Hosting, call tracking and a basic CRM come in the plan.
  • Ready-made investor content and location pages.
  • Training and a large community of investors.

Why investors move off it

  • The bill never stops: about $1,200 to $1,400 a year, more with extra sites ($39 a month each) or the AI Suite ($99 a month).
  • Sellers who compare three investors in your city can see the same layout three times.
  • Carrot’s content library and page templates can’t be used outside Carrot, so leaving means rebuilding.
  • The form, the layout and the code are limited to what the platform allows.
A situation page I built for Volcan Property Buyers: sell an inherited house in Houston The Volcan Property Buyers inherited-house page on a phone
Volcan Property Buyers: Turning 200+ real closed deals into proof: an SEO and page system for a Houston cash buyer’s existing website

Real work

Your company, not a theme

A real investor website I work on: built around the company’s own closed deals, city pages and seller trust, not a template other cash buyers share.

Client websiteVolcan Property BuyersHouston, Texas

Turning 200+ real closed deals into proof: an SEO and page system for a Houston cash buyer’s existing website

Read the case study: Volcan Property Buyers

Side by side

Carrot or a custom website: side by side

Both can bring in motivated sellers. The difference is what you pay over time, what you own, and how much the site can look and work like your company.

QuestionCustom website (me)Carrot (Individual plan)
Price$1,200–$1,500 one time for a full site, then hosting (about $10 a month)$119 a month, or $99 a month billed yearly
Over 3 yearsAbout $1,560 to $1,860 with hosting$3,564 to $4,284
Extra markets or brandsMore city pages on the same site, or a second site at a one-time price$39 a month for each extra site
Who owns itYou: the code, design, content and leads. Move to any host, any time.Your own words, yes. Carrot’s content library and templates stay with Carrot.
DomainYours (I can set it up in your name)Yours: Carrot doesn’t sell domains, you connect your own
DesignDesigned around your brand, your market and how your sellers decideShared themes with your logo, colours and photos
Lead formAddress-first, two short steps, built for your offerCarrot’s form tools within the theme
LeadsSaved in your own dashboard first, then emailed and sent to your CRMCarrotCRM (free plan included) and integrations
Time to launch1 to 3 weeks after you approve the free mockupSame day to a few days
Best forInvestors who spend on mail or ads and want to stand out and own the assetInvestors starting out or testing a new market

Carrot plans, add-ons and terms from carrot.com/pricing, checked 17 November 2026. Prices change, so check theirs before you decide. Hosting estimate: typical renewal price for a small site on shared hosting. I’m not affiliated with Carrot; Carrot is a trademark of its owner.

See the difference on your own brand. I’ll design your new homepage in about 48 hours, free.

Free website check

Check your Carrot site first

Run the free website check on your current Carrot site: phone speed, Google SEO, lead capture, AI search and compliance, scored in about 20 seconds. You’ll know exactly what a move would fix.

  • Free, no email needed
  • About 20 seconds
  • 35+ checks

The switch

How I move you off Carrot without losing rankings

Your Carrot site stays live the whole time. Sellers and Google never see a gap, and you only cancel Carrot once the new site is up.

  1. List every page that brings sellers

    From Google Search Console and your Carrot site map: every address that gets clicks, calls or rankings.

  2. Your free homepage mockup

    A new homepage for your company, designed around your market. You decide before paying anything.

  3. Rebuild with your own words

    Your pages, reviews, photos and videos come across. Anything from Carrot’s content library is rewritten fresh.

  4. Keep or redirect every address

    Pages keep the same URL where possible; every other one gets a 301 redirect to the right new page.

  5. Keep your numbers working

    Your business number, plus any tracking numbers on mail still in the field, so no call is lost.

  6. Launch, then cancel Carrot

    I point your domain at the new site, test every form and redirect, and then you cancel. Save your leads from Carrot first.

124 of 159old page addresses stay exactly the same in the Senna House Buyers redesign, and the other 35 each get a 301 redirect to the right new page. See the case study

Stay or switch?

Is moving off Carrot right for you?

Switching isn’t right for everyone. A quick way to tell:

Stay on Carrot if…

  • You’re testing one new market and have no budget for a website yet.
  • You mostly need a page to send direct-mail traffic to.
  • You use Carrot’s training and CRM every day and they work for you.
Not sure? Check your current site first

Switch to your own website if…

  • You spend every month on mail, PPC or Facebook ads.
  • Several investors in your city use similar-looking sites.
  • You want a site that looks like your company, and that you own.
  • You’ve paid Carrot for a year or more and plan to stay in business for years.
Get my free mockup

Questions about leaving Carrot

Straight answers to what investors ask before they switch.

Something else? Ask me on WhatsApp or email me.

All questions

What is the best Carrot alternative for real estate investors?

It depends on what you want to change. If you just want a cheaper monthly template, other investor site builders exist. If you want to stop paying every month, stand out from other cash buyers and own the website, a custom we-buy-houses site is the better alternative: one price, your design, and your pages moved so you keep your rankings.

How much does a Carrot website cost?

Carrot’s pricing page (November 2026) lists the Individual plan, one website, at $119 a month, or $99 a month billed yearly, with no setup fee. Extra sites are $39 a month each, the AI Suite $99 a month and Premium Support $69 a month. Over three years that’s $3,564 to $4,284 for one site.

Is Carrot worth it for real estate investors?

It can be while you test a market: it’s live in a day and includes hosting and a basic CRM. Once you spend on mail or ads every month and compete with other investors on similar-looking sites, a custom site you own usually costs less over time and stands out more.

How much does it cost to switch from Carrot?

A full custom investor website is $1,200–$1,500 one time, and moving your pages, reviews and redirects is part of that price. Hosting is about $10 a month, paid to the hosting company. Compared with Carrot’s Individual plan ($99 to $119 a month), you save about $1,700 to $2,700 over three years.

Will I lose my Google rankings if I leave Carrot?

Not if it’s done carefully. I list every page that brings visitors, keep the same address where possible and add a 301 redirect for the rest, and the new site goes live before you cancel Carrot. A faster, clearer site often ranks better afterwards.

Can I keep my domain name?

Yes. Carrot doesn’t sell domains, so yours is registered with your own domain company. At launch I point it at the new website; nothing about the name changes.

Can I take my Carrot content with me?

Content you wrote yourself, yes, along with your reviews, photos and videos. Carrot says its content library articles and page templates can’t be used outside Carrot, so I write those pages fresh, for your market.

What happens to my leads and phone numbers?

Save every lead and form entry from your Carrot account before you cancel. Your own business number stays the same. For Carrot call-tracking numbers printed on mail that’s still out, ask Carrot whether they can be moved before you cancel; if not, plan the switch around your mail schedule.

How long does the switch take?

You get the free homepage mockup in about 48 hours. The full site takes 1 to 3 weeks after you approve it. Your Carrot site stays live until the new one is ready, so there’s no gap.

See your new homepage before you leave Carrot

Send me your Carrot site’s address. I’ll design your new homepage within about 48 hours, free, so you can compare them side by side.

WhatsApp Get a free mockup